Toronto van attack man who used autism as an excuse for his crime is found guilty

Friends and families of the victims of the Toronto van attack
Friends and families of the victim of the horrific 2018 van attack embraced outside Toronto Courthouse following the verdict of Alek Minassian

A 28 year old autistic man from Toronto, Ontario – who admitted to killing 10 pedestrians using a van was found guilty on Wednesday 3rd, after a case which brought attention to loneliness, anger and misogyny. 

Alek Minassian and his lawyer Boris Bytensky argued that Minassian did not know what he was doing when he went through with his horrific crime because ‘he was autistic,’ angering the Canadian autism community. 

He pleaded not guilty and his lawyer Bytensky said that autism was the reason his client was not criminally responsible, by only making him understand the severity of his actions at an “intellectual” level.

Autistic people and their allies feared that this high-profile case in Canada would set a worrying precedent, and would falsely link autism with violence.

“People on the autism spectrum are more likely to be victims of violence than perpetrators of it,” said a spokesperson for Autism Canada shortly after the verdict was given.

Justice Anne Molloy rejected the defence argument saying that Alek Minassian’s autism diagnosis was not the reason for carrying out Toronoto’s worst mass murder, which killed 10 people and injured another 16.

Canada’s The Star said it was the first time that anyone had used an autism diagnosis as the sole basis for not being criminally responsible, a claim autistic activists say is demeaning. 

Ontario Autism Coalition also gave a statement following the verdict, hoping it “can now lift the dark cloud that has hung over this trial, with a firm rejection of the use of autism as a defence in this case.

“The court’s decision makes it clear this was never a case of autism causing mass murder, but rather a case where someone who committed mass murder happened to have autism.”

Justice Molloy focused on Minnassian’s clear intentions of carrying out the murders, and referred to a desire to seek notoriety, she rejected the defence’s argument that the defendant was unable to rationalize his decisions, saying his actions were premeditated. 

“His attack on these 26 victims that day was an act of a reasoning mind,” Justice Molloy said.

“He was capable of understanding the impact it would have on his victims. He knew death would be irreversible. He knew their families would grieve.”

For autistic advocate Michau van Speyk, who is a board member of Ontario Autism Coalition, said hearing the judge say these words was a huge relief. 

Van Speyk watched the trial, which was held on Zoom and said it was extremely stressful, both as an autistic advocate and also as a former grade school classmate of one of the victims. 

22-year-old University of Toronto student Ji Hun Kim was one of Alek Minassian’s victims who was known to Michau van Speyk.

“Trying to use autism as an excuse was going to set a dangerous precedent if it went through, but luckily it did not”

“We know that there are consequences of every action, and [autistic people] perfectly capable of making rational decisions,” said van Speyk.

Sam Crane, legal director for the Autism Self Advocacy Network, said it’s always been clear that the driving factors in Minassian’s crime were misogyny and extremism. 

At times, Minassian claimed to be an ‘incel’ — an extreme, misogynist group of men who claim they’ve been unfairly denied sex — and Minassian had been rejected by women several times and wanted to incite an uprising.

Speaking after the verdict, Crane said “the attacker clearly internalized extreme and hateful ideologies that were the basis of the horrific attack”

“This person knew he was killing people, so the implication that an autistic person who is deliberately killing people can’t be held responsible for their actions solely because they’re autistic, I think is offensive,” Crane added.

Cathay Riddell, one of the survivors who sustained injuries to her spine and a punctured lung, spoke out and said that she believes Minnassian deserves to spend the rest of his life in jail.

“He took lives and he didn’t care and you just have to be accountable for what you do.” said Riddell.

Minnassian’s defence lawyer Boris Bytensky has not said whether his client will appeal.

Exit mobile version