New Zealand trust criticise their ‘out of date’ health service

A New Zealand Advisory Trust criticize their 'out of touch' Ministry of Health that is stigmatizing to autistic people and those with ADHD
A New Zealand Advisory Trust criticize their 'out of touch' Ministry of Health that is stigmatizing to autistic people and those with ADHD. Image: Daniel Sone

A New Zealand Advisory Trust has criticised their ‘out of date’ Ministry of Health saying it’s classification of autism, ADHD and other neurodevelopmental conditions is creating access barriers.

It comes after a petition was created by New Zealand’s Disability Advisory Trust, which has garnered more than 1500 signatures online.

The petition calls for the New Zealand health ministry to reclassify autism and ADHD as neurodevelopmental disorders, not mental health disorders.

Treating autistic and ADHD people as mental health patients is stigmatizing and unnecessarily stretches mental health services, a major public health concern if it prevents treatment to those that actually need it.

It comes at a time where countries around the world are battling with a mental health epidemic that has emerged with the Coronavirus pandemic.

Nick Stoneman, from the advisory trust and an autistic himself, says “the Ministry of Health claims not to classify autism and ADHD as mental health conditions, but people with these conditions far too often end up within the mental health system.

“The main problem with this was the wait time for a diagnosis. It varies between the District Health Boards so it could be anywhere between three months and two years, depending on what their waiting list is,” Stoneman said.

The Advisory Trust wants GPs granted powers to diagnose and prescribe medication for ADHD, referrals to neurologists rather than into the mental health system and reclassifying autism and ADHD as neurodevelopmental disorders.

Stoneman claims this would free up funding for mental health services as people will be diagnosed correctly first time round.

New Zealand’s Mental Health and Addiction Chief Clinical Adviser, Arran Culver said in a statement to NZ Herald, “neither autism spectrum disorder (ASD) nor attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) were classified as mental health conditions.

Ministry of Health recognises ICD-10

“The Ministry used the International Classification of Disease as reference, which classified both ASD and ADHD as neurodevelopmental disorders. In both conditions people are likely to see a range of health practitioners which could include mental health professionals, he said.

“ASD and ADHD are separate disorders and have separate pathways for diagnosis and treatment, but all services should provide a multidisciplinary, evidence-based treatment response.

“Autistic children are generally referred to child development services or child health services.

“ADHD is diagnosed and treated in a range of specialist environments, including child health services, infant child, adolescent mental health services and adult mental health services.”

Robin Wynne-Williams, a paediatric practice nurse has worked with ADHD and autistic patients for 30 years, and claims that the lived experience of neurodivergent people with these conditions suggests otherwise.

“ASD and ADHD patients are often referred into the mental health system, where they could wait years for a diagnosis”, said Robin.

She also argued that many New Zealand practitioners refer to the DSM-V – which has it’s own classification of autism and ADHD.

But New Zealand’s Ministry of Health says don’t recognise DSM-V over ICD-10, but admits some clinicians within mental health services may use DSM-V for their own diagnostic purposes.

Wynne-Williams now runs a ADHD information service in Christchurch, which provides post-diagnosis information for neurodivergent people and their families – filling a gap in services available to autistic people and those with ADHD.

Exit mobile version