
I often get asked about what the difference between having a tantrum and an autistic meltdown as somebody who is actually on the spectrum. Anybody that has witnessed the fireworks of anger and and exploding emotion from an autistic person will feel powerless. But you will be surprised to hear how many times a meltdown has been mistaken for a tantrum, in both young children and adults!
To the untrained eye and somebody who is completely oblivious to autism, tantrums and meltdowns may look similar in external behaviour, but they are very different. It’s important to understand the difference between the two if you know an autistic person.
A tantrum is wilful behaviour that has a common goal, and can be shaped by rewarding desired behaviours. A parent of a child (neurotypical children can have tantrums too) will often realise the quickest way to end a tantrum is to give in. But it may not be the best outcome, as I will explain later in this article. A tantrum has an ambition, and the person having the tantrum knows what they want and remain fully in control of their behaviour.
Whereas if you are to have a meltdown, you are not in control. The meltdown is not a tactic to reach a goal, it is a survival instinct and it can be very difficult to understand what a person having a meltdown may need.
Meltdowns never go away, in the same way that temper tantrums tend to in children. Understanding the difference between tantrums and meltdowns is important, because if you was to apply the same response to both, it will only make things worse for a person having an autistic meltdown.
How can you tell the difference?
| Goal orientated vs overload | A tantrum typically stems from frustration and not getting what they want in that moment. They are always goal oriented, such as wanting something from someone. You can detect whether a behaviour is goal orientated by attempting to ignore the tantrum. If they immediately desist or change that behaviour than you know they are in control of their actions and it is a tantrum. An autistic meltdown is about being overwhelmed. If the autistic person reaches a point of sensory, emotional, and information overload, or even just too much unpredictability, it can trigger external behaviours that may appear similar to a tantrum (such as yelling, crying, lashing out). There is no goal for the person having a meltdown. |
| Tantrums require an audience | Tantrum behaviour will usually stop when you ignore the behaviour. Giving in to their demands will also stop their demands but this may necessarily be the best way to deal with the tantrum. An autistic meltdown will occur with or without an audience. They can occur when the autistic person is entirely alone, or withdraws to be alone to have the meltdown in a controlled, safe environment. The meltdown is a response of an external stimulus overload that leads to an emotional implosion or explosion. |
| To put it simply | Tantrums are angry or frustrated outbursts, whereas autistic meltdowns are a reaction to being overwhelmed. An autistic person never has any control over their meltdowns, and never benefits from experiencing them. If an autistic person is having a lot of meltdowns, and you have identified no visible external stimulus, than the stimuli maybe emotional or informational triggers. For example, a past breakup can trigger a meltdown with just internal thoughts and reading up information can also trigger. When this happens, the autistic person is probably suffering from additional mental health problems which is when therapy will be recommended. |
What can you do to help an autistic person experiencing meltdown?
Since a meltdown is the body’s attempt to gain equilibrium by releasing energy, in the same way a Coke can that has been shook so many times will eventually explode, the only thing you can do is be patient.
Safety immediately becomes the primary focus during an autistic meltdown, for the autistic individual and any person in close proximity. An autistic persons first thought when having a meltdown is not to damage anything. However, sometimes their is so much energy inside that it needs to escape. It is why you hear stories of autistic boys harming others and autistic girls harming themselves.
Therapy teaches vital skills how to channel energy inside the body during a meltdown, but this can take practice. An extra couple of seconds processing can mean the difference to finding a pillow to punch to release energy, than smashing a head through a window or slicing yourself.
Boys who have problems channelling energy are more at risk to direct it at something else while girls that have difficulty channelling energy are at risk of harming themselves. Both autistic boys and girls will benefit from mental health therapy to help with the channelling of energy.
| Ensure safety | Autistic individuals can unintentionally hurt themselves or even others during a meltdown. Have a strategy in place, develop an Individual Support Plan (ISP) with the individual. An ISP is basically a contract set out by the autistic person what they need from you when they are unable to communicate. |
| Develop a calming routine | Have an effective calming routine in place. Some autistic people may need others to help calm them, others may need to be left completely alone until they recover. Developing an ISP with the autistic person can help you identify what strategies the individual wants. |
| Record a diary of your emotions | Encouraging an autistic person to record a diary of their emotions, particularly the immediate aftermath of a meltdown can help themselves understand what may have triggered it and work on strategies to prevent it from happening again. Be aware that telling an autistic person what to do may not be the best strategy either, even when they are not in meltdown anymore. It is best to let them come to you when they are ready, but gentle persuasion over time to encourage recording their emotions can help some. |
| Stay calm | Individuals who are patient and remain calm are autistic people’s favourite persons because often autistics that exhibit a lot of internalised energy feel not listened too and ignored. But if you have the patience to help us, then you are one of the people that helps relieve internalized energy rather than add to it – which is a skill autistic people appreciate. |
Goal drive tantrum vs Stimuli response meltdown
Tantrums occur when the person having the tantrum cannot have something they want, so their goal is driven by behaviour designed to persuade whoever is in charge to give in to the desires of the individuals tantrum.
Autistic meltdowns occur as a response to being overwhelmed. Sensory stimuli is one factor for being overwhelmed, but can also be emotional or informational triggers. The processing of the autistic brain is not in sync with the information and thoughts it is receiving, so the stimuli keeps adding more thoughts that can be processed. Eventually, an in-the-now problem becomes an intense emotion, which creates pressure and pressure creates internal energy that hasn’t dissipated over time, which triggers a meltdown when the autistic brain cannot take anymore emotions.
Example:
Let’s use sensory input as an example. Imagine a Coke can with the can being the autistic person and the Coke inside being the sensory input. Something triggers the can by knocking it over, which creates sensory input – the Coke inside starts to fizz. Now the can is being shaken, and the Coke is starting to fizz even more. Eventually, if you keep shaking the can and attempt to open it, the Coke inside will explode. How do you stop the energy inside from exploding? You cannot, you have to be patient. After the Coke can has been shaken, dropped or beaten – for it to not explode in your face you have to be wait. You can also find other strategies to stop the Coke can from getting shaken, by being more gentle. The same applies to an autistic person, you can prevent autistic meltdowns from occurring by working out strategies with the autistic to reduce and manage stress and sensory input.
Behaviour during the tantrum vs Behaviour during the meltdown
While tantrums are goal driven, autistic meltdowns are not. This plays out with some noticeable differences. For example, a toddler engaged in a temper tantrum will only display the behaviour if someone is near enough to see or hear them. If there is no audience the tantrum will stop.
Autistic meltdowns will occur with or without an audience. The audience is largely immaterial. Whoever is in charge walks away during a meltdown, the meltdown will continue until the energy is spent. If you are the cause of the meltdown, it is possible you maybe adding to it. Individual engaged in a meltdown do not stop to check who their audience is.
Because the autistic meltdown is the body’s attempt to gain equilibrium by expending energy, safety concerns often loom. Safety is often the focus of attention during an autistic meltdown, even for the individual having the meltdown. The goal for the person supporting the autistic at the height of a meltdown is to ensure safety, knowing the meltdown will continue until the energy is spent. There is no stopping a meltdown in progress.