Neuroclastic has been served with legal documents by The Judge Rotenberg Educational Center (JRC) for making ‘false and defamatory statements’ about the Massachusetts non-profit school.
Michael Flammia, 63, a lawyer for the center and board member for Eckert Seamans Litigation Division has accused the autistic-led organisation Neuroclastic of making defamatory statements that are ‘causing harm’ to the JRC.
Eckert Seamans has been representing the JRC for over 30 years and were recently responsible for forcing the United States Food & Drug Administration (FDA) to overturn a ban on using harmful shock devices.
Autism Speaks opposed that federal court ruling citing that the ban put in place since 2020 was to curb the use of harmful shock devices on disabled people.

The attorney spoke in a promotional video for Eckert Seamans before the FDA ruling which previously affected the controversial Judge Rotenberg Center, stated, “The state every ten years tries to shutdown or close the school.
“You can’t shutdown a school based on rumour or bad feeling about it,” said Flammia.
“We have been very successful. We have been representing JRC for many years and we have been able to win every case only because there is nothing else that will help these people.”
Much of the main reason the JRC has been so successful is that opponents have failed to provide evidence of alternatives so lawyers for the educational center get decisions ruled in their favour on a technicality.
The courts often are presented with mitigating and aggravating circumstances when weighing up a decision, and if there is a lack of a suitable alternative than the decision would be to stick with the status quo.
However, autistic elder Terra Vance, Chief Executive Officer for Neuroclastic was presented with the cease and desist notice by Michael Flammia.
The letter which was dated on April 27th, 2022, demands that Neuroclastic ceases any further publication of “false and defamatory statements” about JRC’s treatment program and the immediate removal of false statements from public view.
In Flammia’s legal demand to Neuroclastic, it has accused the organisation of reporting falsehoods such as ‘stripping it’s clients of their consent’, which lawyers representing the JRC deny.
The JRC is the largest private provider of therapeutic shock treatment in the United States and according to Flammia himself, ‘the treatment produces a marked reduction in self-injury and aggressive behaviours in most of the clients who receive about one-shock a week.’
In 2018, the United Kingdom’s Guardian published an article that included a petition by Disability Rights International Executive Director Eric Rosenthal.
The petition was referencing two UN Special Rapporteurs on Torture – Manfred Nowak who visited the JRC in 2011 and Juan Mendez in 2013 who both concluded that the treatment administered was in breach of the UN Convention against Torture.
But although the controversial and widely contested treatment that has been challenged by experts, Autism Speaks, Disability Rights organisations and disabled individuals themselves, some people who chose to use the JRC feel like it is the only alternative available.