The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit has affirmed a District Court decision in favour of Microsoft Corp. against a former executive who tried to obtain accommodations for his autism.
John Thompson originally filed to the Western District of Texas Suit in 2018, which he lost.
The former Microsoft executive was an Enterprise Architect, a senior-level position that serves as a liaison between Microsoft and its clients. Prior to that he was an account technology strategist.
Judge Patrick E. Higginbotham ordered that Microsoft did not fail to accommodate Thompson’s disability, discriminated against him or created a hostile working environment.
In the appeal ruling filed June 22nd, Thompson said that he made efforts to obtain accommodations for his disability in 2015 when he was an account technology strategist.
Some of the requested accommodations included working on one project at a time, provision of an assistant for administrative tasks, and permission to work from home.
During negotiations for these requested accommodations, Thompson expressed an interest in transferring to the Enterprise Architect role.
Microsoft informed Thompson that some of his requests were incompatible with becoming an Enterprise Architect, because the position requires “strong leadership and people skills.”
Thompson subsequently withdrew his requests for accommodations and asked that his new manager be informed of his autism diagnosis. He was hired as an Enterprise Architect in Austin, Texas – relocating from New Jersey, and began work in the fall of 2015.
Despite initial positive feedback, Thompson’s manager indicated concerns with his skillset for the role, specifically his experience and ability to lead the required business framework for the client.
At one point, the client Enterprise Holdings requested that Thompson would no longer continue on the job, and Microsoft removed Thompson in January 2016.
At this point, Thompson revealed to his Enterprise Architect manager that he was autistic.
Microsoft’s Human Resources temporarily removed Thompson from the Enterprise Architect pool, meaning he was no longer considered to be added to any other engagements.
Thompson submitted a second formal request for accommodations on April 2nd, 2016 which included,
- a noise-cancelling headset
- specialized job coach with experience coaching executives/technologists with ASD
- training classes on managing ASD and ADHD
- an individual to assist in interpreting verbal information into written format
- a scribe to record meeting notes
- an assistant to help with administrative tasks
- a handheld voice recorder
- specialized software to aide with time management
- an advocate for performance reviews
On May 16th 2016, Microsoft informed Thompson that it agreed to some of the requests, including a noise-cancelling headset, specialized job coach, time management and organization software, and providing training to Thompson’s managers on managing autistic employees but found the others unreasonable.
Microsoft raised concerns about providing an assistant to help translate verbal communication for Thompson in to writing, because Enterprise Architect’s were expected to clearly communicate ideas to their clients and that using a person with less or no experience would devalue the work product.
Additional negotiations continued in to July to seek reasonable adjustments, but Microsoft ultimately decided that they could not accommodate Thompson as an Enterprise Architect and sought to place him on a job-reassignment process.
Thompson objected to being reassigned, and began working with him to find an open position with his requested accommodations in mind, but expressed no interest in any further position as did not want to consider jobs outside of Austin, Texas or a lower paid salary.
The appeal court considered three violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) in regards to Thompson’s role as an Enterprise Architect.
The court ruled that Thompson did not qualify for accommodations because he could not perform fundamental job functions. The ruling highlighted that hiring someone to work with Thompson on a full-time basis would be employing someone to do functions Thompson was expected to do.
A claim for discrimination was also denied for the same reason, and that no hostile working environment took place, as throughout the interactive process, Microsoft worked with Thompson in good faith to seek a solution.
