The United Kingdom’s Autism Research Centre (ARC) announced last week, August 24th, the launch of the largest and most ambitious research project to understand autism better.
Spectrum 10K is led by researchers at the University of Cambridge alongside the Wellcome Sanger Institute and University of California Los Angeles (UCLA) to study and collect data how biological and environmental factors impact autistic individuals.
The levels of additional support needed by autistic people varies considerably, with some requiring lifelong intervention of care plans and support packages, while other autistic people have better outcomes of independent living.
What can be determined at present is that there is not enough support to meet demand. Several governments have been wracking with the problem of trying to work out who needs what support for several decades now.
In 2010, the coalition government brought about a radical program to reassess all disabled people in the United Kingdom, under the belief held at the time that previous system was unfair.
By the end of that term, evidence began to emerge that it was actually costing the government more money to reassess those claiming, and that thousands who had wrongfully lost support were getting them back through the appeals process and the courts.
We do not want to be in a position again where autistic people who lose access to services and support that they need, have to fight for them to get them back. Not only is it unfair on people who lose their support, but it is unnecessarily costly for the taxpayer.
Government needs to accommodate for the needs of everyone, and in the past there has been a lack of data on those receiving support so when you need to make changes or savings somewhere, unless you have the data to explain otherwise why they should keep that support, than you are always at risk of losing it.
Chris Packham, British naturalist and TV presenter, who is autistic and an ambassador of Spectrum 10K said: “I believe in the value of science to inform the support services that autistic kids and adults will need.”
Paddy McGuinness is also excited about the project, explaining: “As a parent of three autistic children, I am really excited to support Spectrum 10K. This research is important to help us understand what makes every autistic person different, and how best to support them.”
And this is what Spectrum 10K plans to achieve, to collect a comprehensive list of data what autistic people need throughout their lives.
Spectrum 10K plans to recruit 10,000 autistic people and their families across the United Kingdom, to listen to them what they need in their lives and what they struggle with.
Professor Simon Baron-Cohen, who is leading Spectrum 10K and is also Director for ARC “There is an urgent need to better understand the wellbeing of autistic individuals. Spectrum 10K hopes to answer questions such as why some autistic people have epilepsy or poor mental health outcomes and others do not.”
But some autistic people are concerned, believing that the project has sinister intentions. First of all, eligible participants have to join by completing an online application and than provide a DNA saliva specimen, which a spokesperson for the research project says will be used to ‘increase understanding and wellbeing of autism’.
DNA concerns
Exactly what participants DNA would be used for has not been officially communicated by Spectrum 10K, but Baron-Cohen says they plan to examine additional physical health conditions such as epilepsy and depression.
Some in the autistic community opposed to the pro-science research project believe the use of DNA samples collected by researchers could be used again in the future.
Amidst the backlash, another spokesperson of the research project was keen to stress “[Spectrum 10K] views autism as an example of neurodiversity and is opposed to eugenics or looking for a cure for preventing or eradicating autism itself.”
Multiple-award winning autistic advocate Siena Castellon declined an offer to be on Spectrum 10K’s Advisory Panel, which consists of autistic individuals, parents of autistic children, clinicians, and autism charity representatives over concerns how the DNA would be used.
All DNA samples collected in the United Kingdom have to be destroyed within 6 months of being taken, although the exception to this, is if a sample is required as evidence in court, in which case it can be retained under the Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996.
However, Baron-Cohen has gone on record in saying in 2009 that a pre-natal test for autism is ‘coming closer’, which will ultimately give couples the choice if they want to have a baby with the condition.
He did say that caution is needed to ensure associated talents are not lost to the test, suggesting that autistic babies more likely to live independent lives should be exempt from the excluded.
Which would make a lot of autism support services and charities around the United Kingdom redundant over night, if all the autistic people requiring additional supports were no longer to around.
This kind of screening is not unheard of as it already exists for detecting Down’s syndrome in unborn babies, but it does raise potential unethical questions, should parents be given the opportunity to terminate a pregnancy.
While there are some excited at the project, including television presenter Paddy McGuinness and Chris Packham, we have to assume that this is where the technology is headed for a potential screening for autism.
We have to be very careful where this takes us in the future and who will have the autonomy to make such decisions.
